Judy Greer

Janice LaRue

Alexander Skarsgård

Ron LaRue

Alison Pill

Lisa Graff

Tracy Letts

Bill Verne

Paul Sparks

Steve Calhan

Annie Parisse

Stephanie Grazer

Kate Arrington

Jill Yardling

Nation Sage Henrikson

Eric LaRue

Jacob Alexander

Brad Gilbert

Jennifer Engstrom

Laura Gates

Mierka Girten

Sheila Guffy

Lawrence Grimm

Jack McCoy

David Pasquesi

Documentary Narrator

Sierra Foley

Rachel Fuller

Marylouise Burke

Wilma Kentworthy

Shea Pritchard

Teen #1

Jalen Michael Black

Teen #2

Jaylee Kennedy

Teen #3

Ridge Lewis

Young Victim

Jack Davis

Young Victim

Ryan Sharp

Young Victim

Chevy Lamont Cofield

Correctional Officer (uncredited)

Kareem L. Alston

Officer J. Rose (uncredited)

Ruth Rhett Bennett

Parishioner (uncredited)

Andrew Donovan

Lisa's Husband (uncredited)

Art Newkirk

Correction Officer (uncredited)

Logan Newkirk

Young Eric (uncredited)

Bobbie Peterson

Prison Visitor (uncredited)

William G. Tomek

Corrections Officer (uncredited)