Barry Watson

Nick DeMarco

Melissa Sagemiller

Carol Guthrie

Scott Grimes

John Guthrie

Tucker Meek

Billy Guthrie

Melissa Joan Hart

Rose DeMarco

Jaleel White

Paul Greenberg

John Ratzenberger

Warden

Wendy Williams

Pastor Ruth

Alimi Ballard

Steve Repperton

John Ratzenberger

Warden Jeffrey Mitchell

Matthew Porter

Walter Banfield

P.J. Marino

Foreman

Dior Raye

Olivia

Andrea Cirie

Mrs. Stanwyck

Lucy DeVito

June

Michael Patrick Lane

Bartender

Brian J. Carter

Ernie

Matthew F. O'Connor

Phil

Bonnie Discepolo

Woman in Bar

Cameron Meyer

Chairwoman

Jonathan Savage

Jerky Kid

Kairo Chelani Ballard

Little Boy 1

Braydon Wilkerson

Little Boy 2

Christopher Savage

Little Boy 3

Charlie Santoyo

Little Boy 4

Mason Lahd Wilkerson

Little Boy 5

Olivia Bell-Cross

Little Girl 1

Destiny Figueroa

Little Girl 2

Naya Seray Ballard

Little Girl 3

Mitch Longley

Mr. Waxman

Enrique Menéndez

Parole Board Member

Brian Hart

Police Officer

Becky Baker

Young Mother

Joseph Basile

Contractor (uncredited)

Erik Bloomquist

Policeman (uncredited)

Elizabeth Hart

Elf (uncredited)

Mackenzie Lee Hart

Elf (uncredited)

William Hart

Poker Player (uncredited)

Hudson Meek

Wiseman (uncredited)

Mark Wilkerson

Sentry (uncredited)