Cristin Milioti

Lucy

Michael Rady

Wade

Toby Huss

Father

James Urbaniak

Glen

Macey Cruthird

Ruth

Katherine Kamhi

Mother

Kristen Ariza

Clare

Noah Staggs

Detective

Chelsey Valentine

Older Girl

Ashanti Brown

Young Mother

Marypat Farrell

Mara

Gail Golden

Janice

Arianna Jaffier

Girl

Elizabeth Krasick

Friend of Ruth

Gena Shaw

Kate

Cordelia Sonnenschein

Younger Girl

Natalie Neurauter

Ruth's Friend