Joshua Schaefer

Peter

Keri Russell

Erica

R.D. Robb

Matt

Mark L. Taylor

Peter's Father

Marcia Moran

Marge

Johnny Green

Nick

Buck Kartalian

Nonno

Catherine Hicks

Ms. Lewis

Patrick Thomas O'Brien

Erica's Father

Darleen Carr

Erica's Mother

Biff Manard

Sad Man

Annie O'Donnell

Sad Man's Wife

Ernestine Mercer

Crazy Lady

Bill Hollis

Mr. Hatfield

Jean St. James

Ms. McCoy (as Jean Pflieger)

Van Epperson

Phil

Vinnie Buffolino

Young Nick

Jonathan Osser

Young Peter

Gabrielle Boni

Mary

Stephanie Sawyer

Young Erica

Taylor Nix

Robert

Jesse Hays

Ten Year Old Peter

Jane Childerhose

Mrs. Olsen

James Pappas

Key Man

Mary Helen Sifford

Permit Lady

Linda Ljoka

Robert's Mother

David Lind

Mailman

Mark Branton

Christian Friend (as Mark Brahyon)

Curt Willoughby

Christian Friend

Amy Ash

Yard Sale Customer

Joel Cohen

Yard Sale Customer

Stuart Coleman

Yard Sale Customer

Hunter Phoenix

Yard Sale Customer (as Angela Hamilton)

Diesmond Lee

Yard Sale Customer

Peter Alexander

Neighborhood Kid

Mandy Matthews

Neighborhood Kid

Kyle Nelson

Neighborhood Kid