Shea Whigham

Phil

Jonathan Scarfe

Nicholas Brady

Michael Rothhaar

Herb Bennon

Katheryn Winnick

Rachel Brady

Scott Wilson

President Fremont

Julie Warner

Newscaster #1

Bruce Hensel

Newscaster #2

Rosemary Harris

VALIS (voice)

John Prosky

Dr. Goldfarb

Kelly Hare

Fremont House Tour Guide

Jon Tenney

FBI Agent #1

Rich Sommer

FBI Agent #2

Joel McKinnon Miller

Berkeley Detective

Peter Holden

Berkeley Cop

Alanis Morissette

Sylvia Aramchek

Hanna Hall

Vivian Kaplan

Mason Cotton

Ezra Brady

Ashley Greene

Rhonda / Delivery Girl

Hugh Holub

Oral Surgeon

Carol Avery

Jan (Secretary)

Kevin McCorkle

TV Anchorman

Licia L. Shearer

Nurse

Richard Cox

Dr. Weinberg

Robert Dolan

FAP Police Guard #1

Alexander Wells

FAP Police Guard #2

Frank Collison

Leon

Joseph D. Reitman

Prisoner #1

Jason Gray

FAP Militia Man 1

Todd J. Thomas

FAP Militia Man 2

Will Rothhaar

Ted Pollett

Maxwell Perry Cotton

Young Nick (uncredited)

Matt Santoro

White House Photojournalist (uncredited)