Ben Stiller

Mike Maxwell

Linda Cardellini

Gretchen Rice

Homer Janson

Justice Kicklighter

Ulysses Janson

Junior Kicklighter

Arlo Janson

Simon Kicklighter

Atlas Janson

Samuel Kicklighter

Toby Huss

Al Wilmington

Maren Heisler

Mia

Edi Patterson

Rose

Tim Heidecker

Deputy Cox

Ari Graynor

Carol (voice)

Ashley Rae Spillers

Barbara (voice)

Lucy Zukaitis

Julia

Bryant Carroll

Security Guard

Louis Heisler

Anthony Biniak

Noah Fisher

Gus

Isabella Steele

Mia’s Friend

Dominick Marrone

Reverend Logan

Vasily Deris

Theater Manager

Jerome Agean

Radio Announcer

Estelle Lapina

Prop Kid #1

Brooks Roseberry

Prop Kid #2

Will Daly

Prop Kid #3

Evan Bartos

Prop Kid #4

Alexander Louis

Gingerbread Man

Rodrigo Almarales

Gingerbread Man Dancer

Jeff Janson

Steve Kicklighter

Melissa Gelfin

Janet Kicklighter

Jenny McManus

Party Guest (uncredited)