Lucy Hale

Eva Vaugh

Jedidiah Goodacre

Kyle

Virginia Gardner

Kelly

RJ Fetherstonhaugh

Jake

Brooke Nevin

Valerie

Brendan Morgan

Mitch

Samer Salem

Norman

Bethany Brown

Robin

JayR Tinaco

Anthony

Edem Nyamadi

Brad

Laura Yenga

Winnie

Pete MacLeod

Finance Scam Date

Kyle Mosonyi

Daddy Dom

Jessimae Peluso

Molly

Sequoia Wiseman

Tara

Threnody Tsai

Lila

Shaughnessy O'Brien

Kayla

Jon Gabrus

Jon

Cam Woodman

Guitar Guy

Nina M. Fillis

Improv Actor

Haley Victoria Hunt

Hunt Sheryl

Brad Abramenko

Man 1

Kendra Hesketh

Server

Justin Lacey

Randy

Spencer Borgeson

Jogger

Zan Klein

Cop

Wayne Corbeil

Townsfolk (uncredited)