Jeremy Jordan

Jacob

Yael Grobglas

Molly

Linda Darlow

Ruth

David Eisner

Gabe

Lisa Horner

Eve

Harry Nelken

Stan

Paula Shaw

Esther

Tim Nhlazane

Thomas

Sam Rosenthal

Ed

Lisa Loeb

Natalie

Linda E. Smith

Liz

Angela Narth

Mrs. Mizansky

Cora Matheson

Emo Girl

Darren Martens

Ezra

Dan De Jaeger

Frank

Debbie Maslowsky

Grandmother

Henriette Ivanans

Owner

Jean-Jacques Javier

Messenger

Saul Elias

Kid

Mariam Bernstein

Mrs. Rosenbaum

Christine Vetus

Waitress

Frederick Allen

Crowd Member (uncredited)

Cindy Rose Myskiw

Gilbert's Deli Regular (uncredited)

Lorrie Papadopoulos

Deli Patron (uncredited)

Angelica Venancio

Waitress

Tia O'Neill

Pebbles

Nico Gentes

Donut Boy